In this seminar, drawing on a two-year collaborative study with six Head Start teachers, the Assistant Professor of Early Childhood Education at the University of Toledo, Katherine (Kate) K. Delaney, discusses the ways in which assessment-driven tools in high stakes early childhood contexts in the United States influenced teachers' notions of young children's "readiness".
While historically the notion of "readiness" in ECE has been framed around children's transition to kindergarten (or the first year of formalised schooling), in this study the teachers reframed the notion of readiness to explain students' preparedness to interact and respond in "high quality" ways as defined by a high stakes evaluative assessment of their classroom quality, the Pre-K Classroom Assessment Scoring System (Pre-K CLASS). Using three vignettes of children's play, and the interpretations of this play by their teachers, Assistant Professor Delaney discusses the ways in which high stakes assessments of classroom quality reframed the teachers' assumptions about what children were and could be capable of.
This reframing of readiness around very specifically drawn "high quality" child/teacher interactions valued by this assessment has troubling implications for the lifeworlds of teachers and children in ECE classrooms. Kate discusses how giving voice to lived experiences with high stakes assessments in ECE settings can open space for teacher and child agency through exploration of the subversive/other(ed) realities hidden by "evidence-based" and "data-driven" policies and practice.